Objective what is the goal of this work, what problem is addressed, what was the current state of the art, who is the work aimed at? Proposal if this paper presents a new idea, what is it? Contributions/claims what contributions does the paper claim to make? Which one is the most significant? Evidence Support for claims – Theorems? Case studies? Simulations? Benchmarks? Does evidence address issues needed to support claims? Shoulders of giants… what previous research does this work build on? What are the key underlying theoretical ideas? Software infrastructure? Impact has this work been influential? When later research papers cite it, what contribution is being referred to? Discussion points End with questions which you think should arise But should also include issues/comments/conclusions which arise from the discussion